Letter to AG Jeff Sessions

Text of former Mayor Carmen Sabatino’s Letter urging the Department of Justice take control the of the Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Department by consent decree.”

Congressmen told of misuse of Federal Funds by Sheriff Adam Christianson.  For more information http://www.backstorynews.com/mayor-sabatino-calls-for-federal-investigation-of-sheriff-da/



The Honorable Jeff Sessions
Attorney General of the United States
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20530-0001

Subject: Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Department

Dear Mr. Attorney General,

As a former duly elected Mayor for the City of Modesto California, I am respectfully requesting that the U.S. Department of Justice intervene immediately in the deepening crisis within the Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Department.   Immediate action is necessary to prevent further damage by our elected Sheriff and reverse eroding public confidence (and public fear) regarding our judicial system. The depth, denial and cover-up of serious misconduct threatens the foundation of our criminal justice system. I am writing solely on my personal behalf, not in official capacity for the City of Modesto.

Years of continuing revelations of scandal emerging from the office under Stanislaus County Adam Christianson is now beyond critical proportions. I am respectfully requesting that you open an investigation at Department of Justice investigation into the continuing allegations of corruption and documented misconduct. As it is within your power to do so, I urge you to take control the of the Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Department by consent decree.

The high-profile scandals have continued to draw scrutiny from the local press for more than 11 years with the office of District Attorney Birgit Fladager continuously embroiled in her own well-documented scandals, we are left “with the fox guarding the chicken coop” In my role as a loyal and concerned citizen as well as prior elected official, I believe the role of “belling the cat” has fallen on my shoulders, and thus this letter to you.  A review of our local press, The Modesto Bee will return endless stories of the Sheriff and District Attorneys misdeeds.  Random examples:

  • Death in custody – The jailhouse death of Former Deputy Craig Prescott. The Sheriff’s office has refused to release the autopsy report, however the families independent autopsy indicated Prescott died from irreversible damage to the brain respiratory failure while being crushed to the floor by eight Sheriff’s Deputies.  Note the Death certificate was never signed.  http://www.modbee.com/news/local/crime/article3142624.html and http://www.modbee.com/latest-news/article3123120.html 
  • Negligent Homicide – The 11-year-old Modesto boy (Alberto Sepulveda) who was fatally shot when an inter-agency SWAT team officers acting on a false narcotics sweep raided his parents’ home. This case was also settled out of court. http://www.cbsnews.com/news/police-kill-11-year-old/ At one point the local paper released an expose that in just the first 6 years of the Sheriff’s tenure, 41 cases had already been lodged against his Department, costing taxpayers $10 million dollars. Since that story, the complaints, lawsuits and settlement have continued to pile up. http://www.modbee.com/news/politics-government/election/article3154321.html  In the absence of public records, the current estimate is over $15 million dollars.
  • False Allegations -The Sherriff in concert with the District Attorney, charged 9 individuals with murder including a prominent local attorney who had run against the DA in the previous election. http://www.modbee.com/news/local/crime/article122482119.html
  • Prosecutorial vindictiveness -Despite two separate Judge’s rulings against various merits of the case and releasing them after 18 months on their own recognizance. Regardless of the District Attorney continues court to the tune of over $8 million taxpayer dollars: http://www.backstorynews.com/court-dismisses-lying-in-wait-special-circumstances/
  • The Sheriff initially provided contractual law enforcement services for the Cities of Riverbank, Patterson, Waterford and Hughson. The Sherriff later reduced each Cities committed law enforcement personnel by one each.
  • On the witness stand, the Sheriff admitted to redirecting Federal funds designated for the Central Valley Gang Impact Task Force, to the Korey Kauffman and AJ Pontiff cases.
  • Targeted Jailhouse discrimination – In jail, Latino inmates are asked whether they are active or former gang members and housed accordingly without the option of saying neither. S. District Judge Lawrence O’Neill stated: “The policy is deficient because it intentionally discriminates against detainees who are suspected of belonging to Hispanic gangs, but not against detainees suspected of belonging to non-Hispanic gangs. the policy … reflects a constitutionally impermissible racial bias against Hispanic inmates.http://www.modbee.com/news/local/crime/article158083684.html
  • Frivolous Spending – The Sherriff sent eight men to a SWAT training center 14,800-mile round trip to Jordan (including a 3-day vacation in Paris). A world class SWAT Training center exists 77 miles away from Modesto. http://www.modbee.com/news/article141865614.html
  • Workplace Harassment – maintains an environment of workplace harassment and irrational repeated behavior towards groups of employees – an example is that in sworn testimony during the hearing of Deputy Dennis Wallace, he was forced to when it was discovered he maintained a list of “limp, lame and lazy employees”.  Deputy Wallace was later killed in the line of duty. http://www.modbee.com/news/local/crime/article3151961.html
  • Discriminatory Employment Practices – During his tenue at the Stanislaus Sheriff’s Department – a marked increase in the layoffs of Assyrian, Latinos and other minority employees.  The Department is increasingly maintaining and recruiting officers of a single mold.

The Sheriff’s actions have left the County, the courts, the judicial system, and the public, no other course of action. I am respectfully requesting that the U.S. Department of Justice begin an investigation and employ all resources to restore order immediately and halt the continuing decay within our County judicial system.


Carmen Sabatino,

Former Mayor of Modesto (2000-2004)




The Honorable Xavier Becerra, Attorney General of the State of California
The Honorable Senator Diane Feinstein
The Honorable Senator Kamala Harris
The Honorable  Doug LaMalfa 1st CD
The Honorable  Jared Huffman 2nd CD
The Honorable  John Garamendi 3rd CD
The Honorable  Tom McClintock 4th CD
The Honorable  Mike Thompson 5th CD
The Honorable  Doris Matsui 6th CD
The Honorable  Ami Bera 7th CD
The Honorable  Paul Cook 8th CD
The Honorable  Jerry McNerney 9th CD
The Honorable  Jeff Denham 10th CD
The Honorable  Mark DeSaulnier 11th
The Honorable  Nancy Pelosi 12th CD
The Honorable  Barbara Lee 13th CD
The Honorable  Jackie Speier 14th CD
The Honorable  Eric Swalwell 15th CD
The Honorable  Jim Costa 16th CD
The Honorable  Ro Khanna 17th CD
The Honorable  Anna Eshoo 18th CD
The Honorable  Zoe Lofgren 19th CD
The Honorable  Jimmy Panetta 20th CD
The Honorable  David Valadao 21st CD
The Honorable  Devin Nunes 22nd CD
The Honorable  Kevin McCarthy 23rd CD
The Honorable Dahle, Brian 1st AD
The Honorable Wood, Jim 2nd AD
The Honorable Gallagher, James 3rd AD
The Honorable Aguiar-Curry 4th AD
The Honorable Bigelow, Frank 5th AD
The Honorable Kiley, Kevin 6th AD
The Honorable McCarty, Kevin 7th AD
The Honorable Cooley, Ken 8th AD
The Honorable Cooper, Jim 9th AD
The Honorable Levine, Marc 10th AD
The Honorable Frazier, Jim 11th AD
The Honorable Eggman, 13th AD
The Honorable Grayson, Timothy S. 14th
The Honorable Thurmond, Tony 15th AD
The Honorable Baker, Catharine B. 16th
The Honorable Chiu, David 17th AD
The Honorable Bonta, Rob 18th   AD
The Honorable Ting, Philip Y. 19th AD
The Honorable Quirk, Bill 20th AD
The Honorable Mullin, Kevin 22nd AD
The Honorable Patterson, Jim 23rd AD
The Honorable Berman, Marc 24th AD
The Honorable Chu, Kansen 25th AD
The Honorable Mathis, Devon J. 26th AD
The Honorable Kalra, Ash J. 27th AD
The Honorable Low, Evan 28th AD
The Honorable Stone, Mark 29th AD
The Honorable Caballero, Anna M. 30th
The Honorable Arambula, Joaquin 31st
The Honorable Salas, Jr., Rudy   32nd AD
Frank Pine, Executive Editor Orange County Register
Editor-in-Chief and Publisher – Davan Maharaj